How The Republic drew on The Iliad

A documented line of influence: Plato demonstrably engaged Homer’s work. The commentary below is Gröblé’s, verbatim from each work’s page.

Relevance
9/10

On The Republic’s page

  • The Republic's most notorious move — banishing the poets — is aimed straight at Homer, and the Iliad supplies the evidence
  • Plato quotes its actual lines (Achilles defying the gods, the gods brawling) as the dangerous content to keep from the guardians
  • Knowing the poem first makes the prosecution land — you can hear exactly which passages Plato thinks are too beautiful and too false to be safe

On The Iliad’s page

  • Homer is the poet Plato can't stop arguing with — the Republic quotes the Iliad directly, only to put it on trial
  • Books 2–3 single out specific passages — Achilles raging, the gods at war — as lies that would corrupt the city's young guardians
  • Book 10 widens the indictment into a full case against Homer as the chief of the mimetic poets: the Iliad is the literature Plato wants to censor

More connections