How The Republic drew on Theogony/Works and Days

A documented line of influence: Plato demonstrably engaged Hesiod’s work. The commentary below is Gröblé’s, verbatim from each work’s page.

Relevance
8/10

On The Republic’s page

  • The Republic's Myth of Metals is Hesiod rewritten — the gold, silver, and bronze souls of the Noble Lie come straight from his myth of the golden, silver, and bronze races
  • Plato names and censors Hesiod in Book 2, then mines him in Book 3; reading the Theogony/Works and Days first lets you watch the theft and the twist
  • Hesiod's tale of decline becomes Plato's instrument of order — the same ladder of metals, repurposed to keep a city in its ranks

On Theogony/Works and Days’s page

  • Hesiod is both target and quarry in The Republic — Plato censors his war-tales of Uranus, Cronus, and Zeus in Book 2, then quietly raids him in Book 3
  • The Noble Lie's gold, silver, and bronze souls are Hesiod's golden, silver, and bronze races reforged — Plato lifts the metallic ladder and bends it to a new use
  • Where Hesiod told a story of mankind's decline, Plato turns the same metals into a myth that holds a city together

More connections