Dorothea and Will Ladislaw

Middlemarch

Influence60th pct
Popularity66th pct
The Age of the NovelThe Victorian Novel

Read this if you…

  • want a book that feels like the author showing off how skilled and complex of a writer they are (in a good way).
  • like the theme of smart intellectuals confronting their own emptiness

Skip this if you…

  • don't enjoy long complex sentences (gotta be patient and really focus)
  • don't like intellectualism generally (can be off putting to some people)

The Groblé Take

Eliot is a very skilled complex writer. Each sentence can link together quite a few thoughts, so it’s a tougher read than most. Has some great insight into internal thinking processes, and all the characters were very believable. Not my favorite, but undeniably well done

Connections

The lineage through Middlemarch

Built Onwhat came beforeWhat It Shapedwhat it set in motionMiddlemarchDon QuixotePenséesThe Divine Come…The Pilgrim's P…Faust, Part TwoThe Portrait of…Howards EndAnna KareninaSons and Lovers

  • Don Quixote by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra. Middlemarch built on it. - The epigraph to Chapter 2 is pure Cervantes — the Don and Sancho arguing over Mambrino's helmet, dropped in just as Dorothea meets Casaubon - Read Dorothea as Don Quixote's heir: a noble, idealizing imagination that mistakes Casaubon's dry pedantry for greatness, with a pragmatic Sancho-like Celia at her side - *Don Quixote* is the template Eliot is consciously continuing — idealism, then reality's correction
  • Pensées by Blaise Pascal. Middlemarch built on it. - Dorothea Brooke's ardent, austere intelligence is cut from Pascal's cloth - *Middlemarch* tells us she 'knew many passages of Pascal's *Pensées* by heart' and that marrying Casaubon 'would be like marrying Pascal' — read the *Pensées* and you understand both her longing and her mistake - Pascal stands behind two of Eliot's chapter epigraphs too; he's the moral and intellectual key to Dorothea's whole arc
  • The Divine Comedy by Dante Alighieri. Middlemarch built on it. - Eliot, a lifelong reader of Dante in Italian, threads the *Divine Comedy* through *Middlemarch* as a metaphor for moral growth wrung out of suffering - Chapter 19 carries a *Purgatorio* VII epigraph — the slothful soul, cheek on palm — framing Dorothea's disillusioning Roman honeymoon - Knowing Dante's terraces of purgation deepens what Eliot is doing with provincial ambition and slow, painful change
  • The Pilgrim's Progress by John Bunyan. Middlemarch built on it. - Eliot heads Chapter 85 of *Middlemarch* with Bunyan — the trial of Faithful, lifted straight from Vanity Fair - *The Pilgrim's Progress* was the book of her Midlands girlhood, and she kept this epigraph when she cut others, so it's no idle ornament - Reading Bunyan first lets you hear what Eliot is doing: setting a worldly courtroom against the Protestant allegory of a soul on trial
  • Faust, Part Two by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Middlemarch built on it. - Behind *Middlemarch* stands Eliot's long apprenticeship to Goethe — the German she translated, the *Life of Goethe* she helped Lewes write in Weimar - It's lineage more than direct quotation: Goethe taught her the patient, unsentimental study of a soul's development, and that's the spirit of Dorothea's story
  • The Portrait of a Lady by Henry James. Middlemarch shaped it. - James reviewed *Middlemarch* in 1873 and never got over it — he praised Eliot's attempt 'to render the expression of a soul' in Dorothea, and vowed his own work would have 'less brain than *Middlemarch* but more form' - That vow is *The Portrait of a Lady*: Isabel Archer's disastrous marriage consciously echoes Dorothea's to Casaubon - In his 1908 preface James named Eliot's heroines as influences — Dorothea is the figure standing directly behind Isabel
  • Howards End by E.M. Forster. Middlemarch shaped it. - The most cited ancestor of _Howards End_. Forster inherits Eliot's confident, intervening narrator — the omniscient voice that pronounces not just on characters but on England and the human condition — then turns it slightly worldlier and more ironic. - _Howards End_ reworks an Eliot plot device outright: Ruth Wilcox's deathbed bequest of the house, scrawled on a scrap of paper and destroyed by her family, is the suppressed-will machinery Eliot built her provincial study around. - Forster's title — a country house standing for England's contested future — places his book in the lineage of the English novel as Eliot defined it: the house, the inheritance, the moral weight of land.
  • Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy. Middlemarch shaped it. - George Eliot was one of the novelists Tolstoy named as a great influence on his major years — and *Middlemarch* sat in his library as he wrote - Eliot's method — a whole provincial society rendered through interlocking marriages and moral lives — is the loom *Anna Karenina* runs on
  • Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence. Middlemarch shaped it. - "It all started with George Eliot," Lawrence said, "it was she who put the action on the inside." He read her in his formative years and credited her with inventing the novel where the real events happen in the mind rather than the plot. - That interiorized realism is the line Lawrence picks up and pushes into modernism, trading Eliot's wide social panorama for the close, unsparing anatomy of one family's inner life.
Gallery

Depicted in Art

Celia Brooke posed in white and lavender, as Eliot describes her — 'all in white and lavender like a bunch of mixed violets.'

William Ladd Taylor, 1889

Dorothea Brooke and Will Ladislaw in conversation — the slow-burn romance Eliot withheld until the final chapters.

1910

Mary Garth and Fred Vincy — Eliot's quiet second couple, set against the Casaubon-Dorothea and Lydgate-Rosamond plots.

1910

Rosamond Vincy and the young doctor Tertius Lydgate — the marriage that destroys his ambitions and her social hopes.

1910

Dorothea discovers Casaubon slumped on a bench in the garden summer-house, his face hidden by a blue cloak.

William Ladd Taylor, 1889

Editions

Recommended Editions

#1Top Pick$12.00$11.18

Penguin Classics

2003

Rosemary Ashton's Penguin is the current default. Notes that situate Eliot's intellectual life and the provincial 1830s setting without crowding the page, and a sober introduction on what the novel's actually doing.

Please support us by purchasing through these links, at no extra cost to you!

Notable Quotes

The growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts; and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs.

Closing paragraph, Finale
Adaptations

Screen & Stage

Posters via The Movie Database (TMDB)

AcclaimPraised by 10 notable voices
  • Stephen Hawking, theoretical physicist, cosmologist, 1942–2018: Chose Middlemarch as his book on BBC Radio 4's Desert Island Discs (1992).
  • Virginia Woolf, novelist & critic, 1882–1941: "The magnificent book which, with all its imperfections, is one of the few English novels written for grown-up people."
  • Emily Dickinson, American poet, 1830–1886: "What do I think of glory — except that in a few instances this “mortal has already put on immortality.” George Eliot is one."
  • Henry James, novelist, 1843–1916: "Middlemarch is at once one of the strongest and one of the weakest of English novels."
  • Martin Amis, novelist, 1949–2023: "They've produced the greatest writer in the English language ever, George Eliot, and arguably the third greatest, Jane Austen, and certainly the greatest novel, Middlemarch."
  • Julian Barnes, novelist, b. 1946: "Middlemarch is probably the greatest English novel."
  • Greta Gerwig, filmmaker, director of Little Women (2019) and Barbie (2023), b. 1983: "Glorious, sprawling, generous … truly a novel for adults."
  • Rebecca Goldstein, philosopher & novelist, b. 1950; MacArthur Fellow; National Humanities Medal 2015: "It's not only my favourite philosophical novel, it's my favourite novel."
  • Sigmund Freud, neurologist & founder of psychoanalysis, 1856–1939: Read and admired Middlemarch in the 1870s–80s; its four volumes lay before him as he wrote to his fiancée Martha Bernays.
  • Harold Bloom, American literary critic, 1930–2019: "No one after George Eliot has achieved the peculiar and invaluable synthesis, in Middlemarch, between the moral and aesthetic."